Comparison of four species-delimitation methods applied to a DNA barcode data set of insect larvae for use in routine bioassessment

Bryan P. White, 1, Erik M. Pilgrim, 2 , Laura M. Boykin, 3 , Eric D. Stein, 1 , and Raphael D. Mazor 1

1. Southern California Coastal Water Research Project, Costa Mesa, California 92626 USA

2. US Environmental Protection Agency, Ecological Exposure Research Division, National Exposure Research Laboratory, Cincinnati, Ohio 45268 USA

3. ARC Centre of Excellence, Plant Energy Biology, M316, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley 6009, Western Australia, Australia


Species delimitation (grouping individuals into distinct taxonomic groups) is an essential part of evolutionary, conservation, and molecular ecology. Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) barcodes, short fragments of the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene, are being used in environmental bioassessments to assign specimens to putative species, but no method for delimiting DNA barcodes into species-level entities is universally accepted. We investigated the effect of delimitation methods on outcomes of bioassessments based on DNA barcodes. We used 2 tree-construction methods (neighbor joining [NJ], maximum likelihood [ML]) and 4 classes of species-delimitation criteria (distance-based, bootstrap support, reciprocal monophyly, and coalescent-based) with a DNA barcode data set consisting of 3 genera and 2202 COI sequences. We compared species delimitations for Baetis (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae), Eukiefferiella (Diptera:Chironomidae), and Simulium (Diptera:Simuliidae) from different streams. We assessed congruence among trees and compared species abundances and estimated species richness among methods. NJ followed by use of a standard barcoding distance cutoff (2%) yielded the greatest number of putative species. All other delimitation methods yielded similar, but lower, richness. Differences in species delimitations produced by various methods might have been caused by confounding factors, such as possible parthenogenesis in Baetis and rare haplotypes in abundant species of Baetis and Simulium. Eukiefferiella presented the fewest discrepancies among delimitations. Each method can be regarded as producing a separate line of evidence contributing to the delimitation of separately evolving lineages. The increased resolution offered by DNA barcoding can yield important insights into the natural history of organisms, but the power of these observations is limited without the use of multigene and multilocus data sets.

Download the PDF: Comparison of four species-delimitation methods applied to a DNA barcode data set of insect larvae for use in routine bioassessment

bpwhite/comparison_species_delimitation_dna_barcoding.txt · Last modified: 2020/02/22 10:59 by bpwhite